ZIWI Peak vs Open Farm: which air-dried dog food scores higher?
Open Farm scores 76 and ZIWI Peak 68. Open Farm names a board-certified nutritionist; ZIWI makes its food itself and costs less per calorie.

Air-dried dog food: where each stands out
Open Farm Air Dried scores 76 (B) to ZIWI Peak’s 68 (C), and the gap comes from nutrition standards. Open Farm names an in-house board-certified veterinary nutritionist and describes test-and-hold safety testing. ZIWI makes its food in its own New Zealand kitchens and costs less per calorie. The two score close on owner ratings.
| Open Farm Air Dried | ZIWI Peak Air-Dried |
|---|---|---|
Grade | B (76) | C (68) |
Nutrition standards | 18.0/30 | 9.6/30 |
Owner ratings | 17.7/30 | 18.3/30 |
Recall record | 30/30 | 30/30 |
Life stage | Surf & Turf: adult maintenance. Pollock & Lamb and Chicken: all life stages, including large-breed growth | Beef: all life stages except large-breed growth |
Who makes it | Partner facilities in the US, Canada, and Iceland | ZIWI’s own kitchens, New Zealand |
Calories | 4,200 kcal/kg (Surf & Turf) | 4,900 kcal/kg (Beef) |
Price per 1,000 kcal (checked) | About $14.43 | About $12.27 |
Which should you choose?
Open Farm, if a named nutrition expert and published testing matter most. ZIWI, if you want the lower cost per calorie and the higher meat content. For a large-breed puppy, Open Farm’s Pollock & Lamb and Chicken recipes are labeled for that growth stage.
Questions
Which has more meat?
ZIWI’s Beef recipe is 96% meat, organs, bone, and green mussels. Open Farm’s air-dried recipes are 90% meat and organs.
Can either be used as a topper?
Yes. Both brands say their air-dried food works as a topper. Cut the main food so total calories stay the same.
Checked November 19, 2026. Full scores: air-dried dog food grades.