Brands
Every brand we grade, sorted by score. Each page shows its score breakdown, who formulates the food, how it’s made, owner ratings, and storage.
A
Purina ONE review: grade A (96/100)
Grade A, 96 out of 100, ranked 1st of 9 dry dog foods we graded. It has 4.8 stars from 6,731 PetSmart reviews, and its Chicken & Rice Formula is backed by an AAFCO feeding trial.
96/100
A
Nom Nom review: grade A (86/100)
Grade A, 86 out of 100, ranked 1st of 6 subscription foods we graded. It names a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, makes its food in its own Nashville kitchens, and has 4.4 stars from 1,871 Trustpilot reviews.
86/100
B
Hill's Science Diet review: grade B (81/100)
Grade B, 81 out of 100, ranked 2nd of 9 dry dog foods we graded. Its adult recipe is backed by an AAFCO feeding trial, and Hill's makes its dry food in its own US plants.
81/100
B
Spot & Tango UnKibble review: grade B (81/100)
Grade B, 81 out of 100, ranked 1st of 6 air-dried foods we graded. It has 4.6 stars from 2,908 Trustpilot reviews, and Spot & Tango says it makes UnKibble in its own Pennsylvania facility.
81/100
B
The Farmer's Dog review: grade B (80/100)
Grade B, 80 out of 100, ranked 3rd of 6 subscription foods we graded. It names three board-certified veterinary nutritionists and funds peer-reviewed research on fresh food.
80/100
B
Royal Canin review: grade B (79/100)
Grade B, 79 out of 100, ranked 4th of 9 dry dog foods we graded. It has 4.1 stars from 7,707 Trustpilot reviews and no dog food recalls found since 2016.
79/100
B
Open Farm Air Dried review: grade B (76/100)
Grade B, 76 out of 100, ranked 2nd of 6 air-dried foods we graded. It leads on nutrition standards, with a named board-certified veterinary nutritionist and test-and-hold safety testing.
76/100
B
Purina Pro Plan review: grade B (76/100)
Grade B, 76 out of 100, ranked 5th of 9 dry dog foods we graded. It has 4.5 stars from 9,293 PetSmart reviews and a 27.6 of 30 nutrition standards score.
76/100
B
JustFoodForDogs review: grade B (75/100)
Grade B, 75 out of 100, ranked 4th of 6 subscription foods we graded. It has the highest nutrition standards score in the group, backed by AAFCO feeding trials and university research on its food.
75/100
C
Sundays for Dogs review: grade C (74/100)
Grade C, 74 out of 100, ranked 3rd of 6 air-dried foods we graded. Owners rate it well and its safety testing is detailed.
74/100
C
Ollie review: grade C (73/100)
Grade C, 73 out of 100. Owners rate it highest of the 6 subscription foods we graded, with 4.7 stars from 11,349 Trustpilot reviews.
73/100
C
Taste of the Wild review: grade C (71/100)
Grade C, 71 out of 100, ranked 6th of 9 dry dog foods and 6th of 10 grain-free foods we graded. It's made in company-owned US plants, and we found no dog food recalls since 2016.
71/100
C
Badlands Ranch Superfood Complete review: grade C (70/100)
Grade C, 70 out of 100, ranked 4th of 6 air-dried foods we graded. Owners rate it well, with 4.2 stars from 2,792 Trustpilot reviews.
70/100
C
Merrick Grain Free review: grade C (68/100)
Grade C, 68 out of 100, ranked 7th of 9 dry dog foods and 9th of 10 grain-free foods we graded. It's made in Merrick's own Texas plants, and we found no dog food recalls since 2016.
68/100
C
ZIWI Peak Air-Dried review: grade C (68/100)
Grade C, 68 out of 100, ranked 5th of 6 air-dried foods we graded. It's made in ZIWI's own kitchens and has a clean recall record.
68/100
C
Pedigree review: grade C (67/100)
Grade C, 67 out of 100, ranked 8th of 9 dry dog foods we graded. Owners give it 4.6 stars on PetSmart, and Mars makes it in its own plants.
67/100
C
The Real Meat Company air-dried review: grade C (67/100)
Grade C, 67 out of 100, ranked 6th of 6 air-dried foods we graded. It has a clean recall record and the lowest cost per calorie of the air-dried foods we could price that way.
67/100
C
Blue Buffalo review: grade C (65/100)
Grade C, 65 out of 100, ranked 9th of 9 dry dog foods and 10th of 10 grain-free foods we graded. Owners give it 4.6 stars on PetSmart, and it names a PhD nutrition scientist.
65/100





