Open Farm vs Sundays for Dogs: which air-dried food scores higher?

Open Farm scores 76 and Sundays 74. Open Farm names a board-certified nutritionist; Sundays leads on owner ratings.

Two dogs in blue and white neck scarves

Air-dried dog food: where each stands out

Open Farm Air Dried scores 76 (B) and Sundays for Dogs 74 (C). Open Farm leads on nutrition standards: it names an in-house board-certified veterinary nutritionist. Sundays leads on owner ratings, with 4.4 stars from 1,226 Trustpilot reviews. Every Sundays recipe is labeled for all life stages, including large-breed puppies. At Open Farm, Pollock & Lamb and Chicken carry that label; Surf & Turf, the recipe we priced, is for adult maintenance.

Open Farm Air Dried

Sundays for Dogs

Grade

B (76)

C (74)

Recall record

30/30

30/30

Nutrition standards

18.0/30

9.6/30

Owner ratings

17.7/30

24.6/30 (Trustpilot 4.4, 1,226 reviews)

Storage

Shelf-stable

Shelf-stable

Life stage

Surf & Turf: adult maintenance. Pollock & Lamb and Chicken: all life stages, including large-breed growth

All four recipes: all life stages, including large-breed growth

Nutrition experts

Dr. Moran Tal-Gavriel, Dip. ECVCN

Board-certified veterinary nutritionists, per Sundays

Safety testing

Test-and-hold for Salmonella, E. coli, and mycotoxins

Test-and-hold for Salmonella and Listeria, plus yearly heavy-metal tests

Calories

4,200 kcal/kg (Surf & Turf)

About 5,400 kcal/kg (Beef)

Price checked

$54.99 for 2 lb

$89 for 36 oz

Which should you choose?

For an adult dog where a named nutrition expert matters most, Open Farm has the edge. If you weigh owner reviews heavily, Sundays is the better fit. Both hold every lot until pathogen tests come back clear.

Questions

Is Open Farm or Sundays better for puppies?

Either works if you pick the right recipe. All four Sundays recipes are labeled for all life stages, including large-breed puppies. Open Farm’s Pollock & Lamb and Chicken air-dried recipes carry the same label, and Surf & Turf is for adult maintenance.

Which costs more per calorie?

At the prices we checked, Open Farm worked out to about $14.43 per 1,000 kcal and Sundays to about $16.15. Sundays costs less per calorie in bigger bags: the 72 oz bag at $156 works out to about $14.15.

Prices and ratings checked November 19, 2026. Full scores: air-dried dog food grades. Brand pages: Open Farm, Sundays.

Dog Food Notes

Grades are general information about pet food, not veterinary advice. Ask your veterinarian before changing your dog’s diet, especially if your dog has a health condition.