Badlands Ranch vs Sundays: which air-dried dog food scores higher?
Sundays scores 74 and Badlands Ranch 70. Owners rate both well; Sundays details its safety testing and covers all life stages, and Badlands Ranch has more reviews and a lower cost per calorie.

Air-dried dog food: where each stands out
Sundays for Dogs scores 74 (C) and Badlands Ranch Superfood Complete 70 (C). Owners rate both well. Sundays scores higher on nutrition standards, helped by its lot-by-lot pathogen testing. Badlands Ranch has more owner reviews and costs a little less per calorie at the prices we checked.
| Sundays for Dogs | Badlands Ranch |
|---|---|---|
Grade | C (74) | C (70) |
Nutrition standards | 9.6/30 | 6.0/30 |
Owner ratings | 24.6/30 (4.4 stars, 1,226 reviews) | 23.6/30 (4.2 stars, 2,792 reviews) |
Recall record | 30/30 | 30/30 |
Life stage | All life stages, including large-breed growth | Adult maintenance (per retailer listing) |
Where it’s made | USDA-monitored facilities in the US Midwest | USA |
Calories | About 5,400 kcal/kg | 4,300 kcal/kg |
Price per 1,000 kcal (checked) | About $16.15 | About $14.69 |
Which should you choose?
Sundays for puppies and for published lot-by-lot safety testing. Badlands Ranch for an adult dog: it costs a little less per calorie at the prices we checked and has more owner reviews.
Questions
Who formulates Badlands Ranch and Sundays?
Sundays says its recipes are formulated with board-certified veterinary nutritionists and reviewed by an animal nutrition PhD. Badlands Ranch says the brand was founded in collaboration with animal nutritionists.
Checked November 19, 2026. Full scores: air-dried dog food grades.